Smoker? You’re fired!

More companies are taking action against employees who smoke off-duty, and, in an extreme trend that some call troubling, some are now firing or banning the hiring of workers who light up even on their own time.

The outright bans raise new questions about how far companies can go in regulating workers' behavior when they are off the clock. The crackdown is coming in part as a way to curb soaring health care costs, but critics say companies are violating workers' privacy rights. The zero-tolerance policies are coming as more companies adopt smoke-free workplaces.

Source/Read more at: USAToday

I personally don't smoke, and I try to avoid second hand smoke as much as possible. However, if this trend continued to hospitals/EMS agencies, then a large majority of the workforce would be eliminated. It also sets up a dangerous trend: Are we going to start firing people because they don't exercise, eat poorly, or have a BMI of greater than 25? These are choices an individual makes, yet the entire society bears the burden of that individual choice because the society has to pay for the increasing health care costs of treating the known disease sequelae of that choice. The only fair solution I can think of is let the workers keep their jobs, but they should also be responsible for the choices that they make. Those that choose to impact their health in a negative way should be responsible for the increased cost to society to treat their preventable diseases by paying increased health insurance premiums.


Email Email to Friend PrintPrint

Mom Says:

That sounds logical to me. People have a right to do what they want on their own time and if it is not directly affecting others, but they, not society in general must also carry thr burden of that choice.

 
sonja Says:

I agree that smokers should be hired, as long as they don’t smoke in their place of work, but having to pay more health insurance gets tricky because where does it stop? Should overweight people also have to pay higher insurance? People should be allowed to do what they want in their own time as long as it doesn’t harm others, but the cost-aspect gets tricky. I’m sure there would be plenty of discrimination suits - especially because with obesity, you can’t always say that it’s entirely a person’s fault. Sometimes there are genetic factors or weight-gaining medications involved.

Carsten Says:

I agree — drawing the line at what is choice and what is not would be difficult. Smokers could probably even argue that it is not a choice for them - since it is so addictive.

And would this line of thinking lead to not funding trauma care? Most of that is caused by drunks, and overimbibing in alcohol is definately a choice…

 
 
Subaqua Sternal Rubs » Blog Archive » Overweight Workers Receive Smaller Wages Says:

[…] Workers Receive Smaller Wages An interesting article I found relating to one of yesterday’s posts: Workers who are obese might be receiving lower wage […]

 
Subaqua Sternal Rubs » Blog Archive » Immunology in Action — Vaccine against Smoking Says:

[…] Immunology in Action — Vaccine against Smoking In a followup to a past post, an interesting new study is out testing a vaccine against ni […]

 
Kirsten Says:

I really get pissed off when I see employees smoking on duty or off duty. :mad:

 

If this is your first visit to the site, please see here for commenting rules.

Comment moderation is selectively enabled. If your comment does not appear immediately, it has been held for moderation. Please be patient, and do not resubmit your comment - I will enable your comment as soon as I get a chance to review it. Thanks!

If you are a registered user on this site, please log in before posting your comment. Not only will you bypass the impersonation and comment spam detection mechanisms, you will also have 60 minutes to edit your comment for glaring spelling or factual errors, whereas those not logged in will have to live with whatever is in the box when they hit the submit button.

:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?:

© 2004-2006
Use of this site implies your understanding and tacit agreement to all points in the disclaimer.
Subaqua Sternal Rubs is proudly powered by WordPress 2.0.5 and Gallery2. This page made freshly for you in 0.313 seconds.
Notice to spammers: Spam Karma 2 has automatically deleted 24205 spams that Bad Behavior didn't get. Don't even bother trying.